Skip to content
Sudip Majumder
All articles

How Can OEMs Measure Aftermarket Leakage More Effectively?

Treat leakage as a segmented revenue-flow problem: map the installed base, estimate serviceable demand, compare it with captured revenue and trace where customers exit.

By Sudip Majumder

OEMs can measure aftermarket leakage most effectively by treating it as a segmented, revenue-flow problem: identify the installed base, estimate the serviceable demand it generates, compare actual OEM-captured revenue with that potential, and then trace where, why, and for which customers revenue exits the OEM system. Published research emphasizes that aggregate “captive share” can hide the real issue; the useful measure is leakage by fleet age, geography, customer type, product category, and channel.

Define leakage precisely

Aftermarket leakage is revenue an OEM could plausibly capture from its installed base but does not—because the customer buys parts elsewhere, uses an independent repair provider, defers maintenance, chooses a competing service contract, or never receives a relevant offer. Blue Ridge Partners estimates that aftermarket revenue leakage in heavy and light equipment ranges from 25% to 50% of the revenue an OEM could otherwise capture.

A practical definition

Aftermarket leakage = Estimated addressable aftermarket demand − OEM-captured aftermarket revenue

The key discipline is to make the denominator explicit: not every theoretical part or service need is realistically capturable. McKinsey recommends assessing aftermarket potential through aftermarket lifetime value—the total revenue an OEM can receive from servicing its installed base—rather than relying only on service revenue per customer.

Build the measurement model

Start with the installed base

The first requirement is an accurate, living view of the equipment population: unit age, model, serial number, location, operating hours, warranty status, service history, ownership changes, and expected remaining life. McKinsey finds that aftermarket providers commonly struggle with installed-base visibility and cannot systematically identify underserved accounts, customers at risk of switching, or expansion opportunities.

For heavy equipment, this means combining:

  • Sales and registration records
  • Dealer and distributor transaction data
  • Warranty and repair-order data
  • Telematics or connected-machine data, where available
  • Parts catalogs and bill-of-material data
  • Customer, fleet, and jobsite information

Without this foundation, an OEM cannot distinguish a customer that genuinely needs no service from one that is being served by an independent provider.

Measure demand, not just sales

Estimate the addressable demand pool

For each equipment segment, OEMs should estimate the parts and services the installed base should consume over a defined period. This includes consumables, wear parts, planned maintenance, unplanned repairs, remanufactured components, attachments, software, and field labor.

McKinsey’s approach is to calculate average annual services revenue as a percentage of equipment value—for example, $100,000 of annual aftermarket revenue on a $1 million machine equals 10%. That creates a comparable benchmark across machines with different prices and lifecycles.

A useful measurement hierarchy is:

MeasureWhat it showsWhy it matters
Installed-base coverageShare of units with an active OEM parts, service, warranty, or contract relationshipIdentifies unmanaged or underserved fleets.
Parts captive shareOEM parts revenue divided by estimated parts demand for that fleet or segmentShows where customers buy outside the OEM channel.
Service retentionShare of expected maintenance or repair events captured by OEM/dealer channelsReveals loss to independents, in-house teams, or deferral.
Aftermarket lifetime valueTotal OEM revenue generated per unit over its service lifeConnects leakage to long-term customer economics.
Leakage rateEstimated addressable demand minus OEM-captured revenue, as a share of demandQuantifies the opportunity and enables target setting.

Segment before drawing conclusions

Avoid one global leakage number

A single company-wide captive-share figure can be misleading. McKinsey specifically advises quantifying leakage at the segment level, because an aggregate number can conceal where independent providers are gaining ground and where a low captive share may reflect a deliberate economy-parts strategy rather than a problem.

At minimum, OEMs should segment leakage by:

  • Equipment age and operating hours
  • Product family and parts category
  • Geography and dealer territory
  • Customer type: owner-operator, rental fleet, large contractor, mining operator, or government fleet
  • Warranty, service-contract, and telematics status
  • Channel: dealer, direct OEM, independent distributor, online marketplace, or in-house workshop
  • Part type: critical, wear, cosmetic, remanufactured, or aftermarket-equivalent

For example, a low OEM share of economy parts in an older fleet may be strategically acceptable, while low OEM share for critical, high-value components in a newer fleet may represent genuine leakage. McKinsey’s trucking research makes exactly this distinction between defending premium share and using economy or independent channels to retain volume.

Trace the exit points

Map the customer journey

Leakage measurement should identify the point at which a customer leaves the OEM system—not merely record that revenue was lost. Blue Ridge Partners recommends mapping the flow of aftermarket dollars through the OEM’s system, competitors, and the broader market, then identifying the points where customers must step outside the OEM structure to obtain the service level they need.

Common leakage points include:

  • A customer cannot identify the correct part quickly.
  • The OEM part is unavailable or has a long backorder time.
  • An independent distributor offers faster delivery or a lower landed cost.
  • The dealer lacks technician capacity or cannot schedule service promptly.
  • The customer perceives OEM pricing as opaque or uncompetitive.
  • The customer performs maintenance in house.
  • The customer buys generic, remanufactured, or counterfeit parts.
  • The OEM fails to contact the customer at a service-relevant moment.

McKinsey notes that unavailable parts increase repair time, worsen customer experience, and can jeopardize future revenue; it also identifies pricing inconsistency, competitive substitution, slow-moving inventory, and below-entitlement share as recurring aftermarket challenges.

Use leading indicators

Measure the causes, not only the outcome

Revenue leakage is a lagging indicator. OEMs should also monitor operational signals that predict it. Important indicators include:

  • Parts availability Fill rate, stockout rate, backorder duration, and time to customer receipt.
  • Ordering friction Time to identify, quote, order, and confirm a part.
  • Service responsiveness Time from request to technician dispatch, repair completion, and first-time-fix rate.
  • Warranty performance Claim cycle time, denial rate, dealer reimbursement delays, and warranty leakage.
  • Contract coverage Share of installed base under a service agreement, and renewal or lapse rate.
  • Connected-fleet engagement Share of machines transmitting usable diagnostic or usage data.
  • Customer defection signals Declining parts purchases, missed maintenance intervals, increased third-party purchases, or reduced dealer engagement.

McKinsey identifies technician productivity, the balance between reactive and proactive dispatch, warranty leakage, and knowledge retention as central service-sector challenges. These measures help explain why leakage occurs before it appears in lost revenue.

Validate with external data

Do not rely only on internal systems

Internal data shows what the OEM sold; it does not show what customers bought elsewhere. To estimate total demand and leakage credibly, OEMs should combine internal records with external market data, dealer intelligence, customer interviews, and where lawful and appropriate, third-party market or fleet data.

McKinsey’s aerospace example describes building an analytical model to estimate the size of the aftermarket opportunity, identify upselling opportunities, optimize spare-parts pricing, and explore geographic expansion; that work increased commercial-fleet aftermarket revenue by more than 10% within two years.

For heavy equipment, a practical validation approach is to compare:

  • OEM-recorded parts and service revenue
  • Estimated consumption based on installed base, operating hours, and maintenance schedules
  • Dealer-reported lost sales and cross-shop behavior
  • Customer-reported sourcing behavior
  • Independent-provider and marketplace presence in each territory

Turn measurement into action

Prioritize recoverable leakage

The final step is to distinguish leakage that can be recovered from leakage that should be accepted. Blue Ridge Partners notes that OEMs must assess which leakage points can be plugged and which cannot, then build targeted initiatives around the root causes. A useful prioritization matrix is:

Leakage typeExampleLikely response
RecoverableCustomer leaves because a part is out of stock or delivery is slowImprove inventory, fulfillment, and dealer order visibility.
RecoverableCustomer defers maintenance because value is unclearOffer transparent pricing, condition-based recommendations, and financing.
RecoverableCustomer is unaware of an upgrade or service contractUse installed-base intelligence to trigger targeted outreach.
StrategicCustomer chooses a lower-cost economy part in an older fleetDecide whether to compete on price, offer a value-tier range, or accept the loss.
StructuralCustomer performs repairs in house for capability or cost reasonsFocus on critical parts, technical support, training, and high-value service offerings.

A practical scorecard

OEMs should publish a monthly or quarterly aftermarket-leakage scorecard with a consistent definition across markets. A strong scorecard would include:

  • Installed-base units, active units, and units under coverage
  • Estimated parts and service demand by segment
  • OEM-captured revenue and captive share
  • Leakage rate by segment and channel
  • Parts availability, backorder time, and fill rate
  • Technician response time and first-time-fix rate
  • Service-contract penetration and renewal rate
  • Customer churn, repeat-purchase rate, and third-party purchase signals
  • Recoverable-leakage pipeline and value of corrective actions

The central principle is simple: measure leakage where it happens—at the customer, machine, part, channel, and moment of need—not merely in a consolidated revenue report. That is how OEMs can turn leakage from a vague revenue gap into an actionable operating agenda.

Sources

  1. 01McKinsey — Capturing life-cycle value in Europe’s trucking industry
  2. 02McKinsey — How AI-led commercial transformation can power industrial growth
  3. 03Blue Ridge Partners — Executive brief: aftermarket revenue
  4. 04Blue Ridge Partners — The untapped potential of aftermarket revenue
  5. 05McKinsey — Industrial aftermarket services: growing the core
  6. 06McKinsey — How disruptive technologies are opening up innovative opportunities in services
  7. 07Umbrex — Service retention in dealerships
  8. 08McKinsey — Aerospace aftermarket and services
  9. 09McKinsey — For OEMs in the United States, the aftermarket is fertile ground
  10. 10McKinsey — The hidden growth driver: China’s industrial aftermarket services sector
  11. 11McKinsey — Paving the way for off-highway equipment customers

Next step

Looking for an aftermarket or industrial sales leader?

Open to conversations about senior sales, aftermarket and business development roles in heavy industrial equipment.